The Unexpected Benefits of Working With a Male Therapist

When choosing a therapist, many women instinctively look for another woman. The assumption makes sense: a female therapist might better understand their experiences, particularly when it comes to relationships, motherhood, sexuality, or the challenges of navigating the world as a woman. But what if sitting with your thoughts actually makes you feel worse? But what happens when a woman chooses to work with a male therapist instead?

In a fascinating article in The Cut, "“Why Would You Pay to Talk to a Man?”" https://www.thecut.com/article/the-women-seeking-out-male-therapists.html, Meaghan O'Connell explores the experiences of women who have found unexpected value in working with male therapists.

Some initially felt uncomfortable with the idea. Others deliberately sought out men, hoping that a different perspective might help them understand themselves and their relationships in new ways.

What emerges is an interesting question: Does feeling immediately comfortable with a therapist necessarily mean that person is the best fit for us?

The Value of a Different Perspective

We often gravitate toward people who share our experiences. There can be something reassuring about talking to someone who seems to understand without needing an explanation.

But that familiarity can also lead us to make assumptions.

One woman in the article describes how working with a male therapist required her to articulate experiences she might have taken for granted with another woman. Rather than assuming he understood the emotional complexities of pregnancy or body image, she had to find language for feelings she hadn't fully examined herself.

That process became therapeutic in its own right.

Sometimes being understood immediately is comforting. Other times, having to explain ourselves helps us discover something we didn't realize we were feeling.

Neither experience is inherently better. But they offer different opportunities for growth.

An Interesting Dynamic in Couples Therapy

Perhaps one of the most revealing aspects of the article concerns couples therapy.

Some women described intentionally seeking male therapists because they worried their male partners would feel judged, misunderstood, or outnumbered by a female clinician.

One woman believed her husband would be more receptive to a male therapist, and less likely to interpret therapeutic feedback as another woman taking his wife's side.

Another deliberately chose a gay male therapist, hoping he would offer a perspective that felt less tied to the traditional gender dynamics of their marriage.

These examples raise some fascinating questions about what people bring into the therapy room before treatment even begins.

A husband may expect a female therapist to side with his wife. A wife may expect a male therapist to better understand her husband. Either partner may unconsciously assign greater authority to a clinician based on gender.

And those expectations can shape the therapeutic relationship, regardless of whether they accurately reflect the therapist's approach.

The interesting question isn't simply whether a male or female therapist is better for a couple. It's what each partner imagines the therapist's gender will mean.

  • Does one partner feel safer with a particular gender?

  • Does the other feel threatened?

  • Who is expected to understand whom?

  • And whose perspective is assumed to carry more authority?

These questions can reveal dynamics that exist well beyond the therapy office.

Of course, a good couples therapist doesn't take sides based on gender. The work is to understand the relationship, recognize each partner's experience, and help the couple see the patterns they may be struggling to recognize themselves.

The Relationships We Bring Into Therapy

From a psychodynamic perspective, one of the most compelling aspects of the article is its exploration of transference.

Transference refers to the ways our feelings, expectations, and experiences from earlier relationships can influence how we experience people in the present—including our therapists.

A woman who has spent much of her life seeking approval from men might find herself wanting to impress a male therapist. Someone who has experienced men as critical or emotionally unavailable might anticipate similar treatment, even when the therapist has given her no reason to expect it.

These reactions aren't necessarily obstacles to therapy. They can become some of its most valuable material.

The therapeutic relationship offers an opportunity to notice familiar patterns as they unfold in real time.

  • Why do I feel compelled to earn this person's approval?

  • Why am I so worried about disappointing them?

  • Why does their silence feel like rejection?

And these dynamics certainly aren't exclusive to male therapists.

A female therapist might evoke feelings associated with a mother, sister, friend, rival, or authority figure. A client might feel especially understood by her, or find herself competing for approval, fearing judgment, or longing for a different kind of closeness.

The therapist's gender may influence what emerges in treatment, but it doesn't determine whether the therapy will be effective.

Comfort Matters, but So Does Curiosity

None of this is to suggest that women should seek male therapists simply because the experience might be challenging.

For some clients, particularly those with histories of trauma or difficult experiences with men, working with a female therapist may feel essential to establishing safety and trust. Those preferences deserve to be taken seriously.

And a therapist's gender is only one aspect of who they are. Their personality, clinical skill, emotional availability, cultural understanding, and capacity for self-reflection are all enormously important.

But I think the article invites us to consider something beyond the usual question of whether a therapist seems like someone we'd feel comfortable talking to.

  • What draws us toward certain therapists and away from others?

  • What do we imagine they'll understand about us? What do we fear they won't?

  • And what might those expectations tell us about our relationships more generally?

Sometimes the qualities that initially make a therapist appealing are precisely what allow us to feel safe enough to do difficult work. Other times, an unexpected therapeutic relationship offers an opportunity to explore parts of ourselves we might otherwise overlook.

Ultimately, the most important question isn't whether your therapist is a man or a woman. It's whether the relationship creates space for you to understand yourself more deeply.

And sometimes, even our preferences about whom we'd like to talk to can be a meaningful place to begin.

Next
Next

When Meditation Makes You Feel Worse: Why Good Therapy Isn't One-Size-Fits-All